Round 11 - Parramatta Eels VS Cronulla Sharks *Contains Spoilers*

Discussion in 'Matches' started by Hughesy, May 22, 2010.

  1. Wilson SB Wilson

    I've been suggesting for weeks that Barrett should play lock and everyone laughed at me.
     
  2. Julian BJ Taylor

    Don't think there'd be any point in him playing lock. It'd just lessen your already dominant pack and he'd still play as a five-eighth anyway. Wouldn't have enough in attack as a lock IMO.
     
  3. Wilson SB Wilson

    He'd be doing exactly the same at lock as he would right now.
     
  4. Cribbage RG Cribb

    It'd give them another dimension their attack though. Douglas, Snowden, Gallen and Tupou all play pretty big minutes and they're all huge workers in attack so the forward load would still pretty much be covered, and Barrett could just play as an extra link and focus a lot more on his running game. I think it'd add something to the team.

    Alternatively he could just play centre; I definitely think he'd be a much better centre than Tautai even though it's been a long time since he'd played there.

    Honestly though, the most noticeable thing about the Sharks is just how slow they do everything. There's no crispness to their play at all and the players routinely run contradicting lines. I loathe to blame a coach for a team's failures as teams are often just shithouse, but Cronulla have quite a good team on paper and it's hard to pinpoint areas that make them so bad - I really think Stuart needs to be looked at.
     
  5. Julian BJ Taylor

    2 more NRL standard three quarters and Cronulla have a gun team IMO. Oh....and a fullback.

    What the hell has happened to Matthew Wright? He showed promise last year. Moreso than the likes of Gordon, Tautai and Pomeroy anyway IMO.
     
  6. Cribbage RG Cribb

    Yeah, I really liked the look of Wright. Reminded me heaps of Matt Gidley. He spent the first part of the year playing five-eighth in the 20s, then he started playing lock in the NSW Cup. Now he's finally playing centre in the NSW Cup.
     
  7. Wilson SB Wilson

    Gardner is a gun fullback. You're full of shit if you think otherwise.
     
  8. Julian BJ Taylor

    Why the **** isn't he playing left centre in the NRL. Tautai is at least partially excusable on the wing. Better off ****ing him off completely though. Gordon's not doing anything wrong but he's not impressed me at all really.

    Really disgusted that I'm saying this but short, slight wingers don't really have a place in the NRL these days unless they're just exceptional at what they do. Merritt and Ryan are a couple I can think of that fit that mould.
     
  9. Julian BJ Taylor

    I'm hardly going to agree or disagree considering I've seen him play 80 minutes of football. Even if he's been gun in other grades he's got to prove his worth yet. Hell Bronx Goodwin was a gun in reserve grade and Will Zillman was Clive Churchill reborn.
     
  10. Wilson SB Wilson

    Gordon is unlucky he's outside Tautai. If he was with a good center in a good team he'd be an awesome winger. He's probably the fastest winger but he's pretty solid in defence
     
  11. Julian BJ Taylor

    Yeah I realise that. But there are other wingers outside terrible centres that have looked good in doing so.
     
  12. Cribbage RG Cribb

    Really don't know. The fact that I signed him for 180k in NNRL this year is probably a good indication of what I think of him. :p
     
  13. Cribbage RG Cribb

    Gordon's okay. Yet to be convinced he's better than Stapleton though who seems to get scapegoated all the time.
     
  14. Wilson SB Wilson

    Well I guess you're entited to your opinion but he definitely was the difference tonight with Gallen. He's not a crisp fullback, but **** me he's awesome for his age.
     
  15. Cribbage RG Cribb

    I really don't think changing the team make-up is going to make too much of a difference though - the team itself looks fine. Getting Barrett out of five-eighth might help but the team just looks so slow and poorly coached.
     
  16. Wilson SB Wilson

    Stapleton is a ****ing gun center. It's funny though the time he's given the chance he still dominates and funnily still gets dropped from the position.
     
  17. Julian BJ Taylor

    Wilson I've already agreed with you that Gardner was good tonight FFS.

    It's all I've seen of him though (I think) so I can hardly form any opinion of him at all yet is what I'm saying.
     
  18. Wilson SB Wilson

    Not really what I was arguing. Gordon is awesome in attack yet reliable in defence.
     
  19. Cribbage RG Cribb

    I didn't quote your post though, did I? :p

    Was a general comment on what we were talking about.
     
  20. Wilson SB Wilson

    Yeah well get ****ed ****s! You weren't on fox sports! :p
     

Share This Page