The Wire Mafia III

No because different mods do things differently. In epicmafia the Mafia have first strike. I think this is how it should be done because night killing should a) be something the maf are better at and b) not be the primary way town get things done

 

Of the 8 Mafia probably one was lynched by town in the conventional sense

Hedger, Furball - killed by 3P killer
AVA - lynch led by mafia
Cabinet - lynched by 3P
Cevno, THB, N11, - killed by Mafia
Escath - lynch led by town

this is just what happens with multiple mafias I suppose

 

As I said, I wanted to mafside, but couldn't be 100% sure if I would win if I lynched Blunder.

As an aside, I quite enjoy being 3rd parties. I got up to all kinds of half-truths and shenanigans in this game. Poor Blunder, I must have been so frustrating to him

 

Arbitrary player ranking

1. Heef - had to work really hard to be kept alive by town without seeming so green that mafia would off him, knowing that he would basically control the game at the end. Only told people what he had to in order to stay in the game. Textbook
2. Blunder - basically one of the best ever town performances as a blue. No excuses from now on
3. hedger - surprised people ended up agreeing he was scum, led town for ages. Would have been MVP in a mafia win
4. Captain - very good game, did well to convince town h was needed, without stopping the d4 lynch on him they would have lost. Good reads
5. Cabinet - never put a foot wrong until the captain thing
6. Teacups - seemed very on the ball before being offed, put some effort into a scum read on n11 and others
7. AVA - took some really good play to bring him down
8. Gazza - did his job for a bit, not his fault no one protected him
9. N11 - competent maf qt planning, another who could be called unlucky
10. Quaggas - got a bit unlucky
11. Morgieb - did okay without making any memorable contributions. early role claim did actually help town in hindsight though he didn't mean it that way
12. Skippos, Shiv, THB - a curiously high place to put the N/As. Lots of great play in this game was from relatively few players at the end
15. Arheiner - no outright errors but a daytime power role who barely posted in the day
16. Uppercut - mistake to open claim d1, obviously. lol'd at him giving someone shit in the QT for early claiming
17. Furball - tried to make the best of a shaky situation but the watcher play was not really thought through
18. Cevno - I normally give the n0 dead a free pass, but wasting the janitor kill was an error
19. Teja - post ffs
20. Dougy - actually performed reasonably as a town blue towards the end but that Teacups lynch is one of the most inexplicable moves I've ever seen
21. Raide - n0 vig is always terrible, particularly bad in this game where it cost town their vig and one of three investigative roles
22. Escath - i'm still a bit salty about him not giving anyone a chance to replace him

 

I could be lynched, but not when it was down to 5. If 6 people out of 7 had lynched me, I'd have been toast.

And I was only immune from night kills if my day time target got lynched. When Furball was 'lynched' and Dougy redirected the lynching, I wasn't safe that night as a result.

I was deliberately trying to attract night attacks towards the end when I knew I was able to own the lynch vote, certainly prevented a death on n5. Wouldn't have been a town win otherwise.

 

He would be protected at night if he used his power to hammer a target.

He could be lynched whenever there were more than 6 people in the game.
He could be killed whenever he couldn't swing a vote, or when someone used an unblockable kill on him (maf had 3, town had no doc)

So he started the game pretty much blue and finished it close to unstoppable.

At any rate people could have gotten rid of him at any time by not voting.