Would be a pretty poor debate tbh. 653 @ 55 batting 5 and 735 @ 49 batting at 6. HS of 199 at 5 and a HS of 119 at 6.
But not by much. I wouldnt be too fussed with him at 5 or 6. He has scored more runs at 6 and only averages 6 less. So not much difference. Eds after all our dicussion you ended with Nel!!?? Why
Harsh, but when Nel is pretty much the best of the bunch, it's hard to disagree. Maybe not by a long way though...Boob is pushing him close.
Trial Stats CH Gayle - (17.00) S Butt - (22.50) OA Shah - (7.00) SR Tendulkar - (22.50) DMPD Jayawardene - (25.00) IR Bell - (37.50) YK Pathan - (6.00) S Ahmed - (27.75) DJ Bravo - (22.75) (68.00) SCJ Broad - (25.50) (46.40) PL Harris - (5.00) (28.00) A Nel - (26.50) (38.00) GD McGrath - (7.50) (59.00) Shit trials tbh