Seasonal Rugby: South

Discussion in 'Seasonal Rugby' started by HeathDavisSpeed, Sep 1, 2011.

  1. morgieb MC Burridge

    Aren't there heaps of Irish guys on that other forum?
     
  2. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    There are indeed. And if they get a team over here, then I guess problem solved. That's a fair old way from happening though.
     
  3. Quaggas O du Toit

    KP still eligible for SA's Olympic Flower Arranging Team, iirc.
     
  4. Benny BS Read

    You've barely got enough players for Celtic starting XV though. They've already exhausted dodgy allegiance transfers too to grow so i don't see them finding 5/6 extra players without an effort to do so.
     
  5. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    As Morgie alluded to, I've been looking at potentially having another forum have a team (in reserve grade) for Season 5. If that happens, they have a full team of proper Irish already so it certainly becomes viable at that stage.

    Still, I reckon we can still beat Norths without Skippos and Tartinder so I don't know why we wouldn't go for it.
     
  6. MrPrez CM Dyer

    How about making it emerging provinces - then you'd have guys like me, Droos etc.
     
  7. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    I really don't like that idea. I'd prefer to see South Africa be South Africa - even if they don't have a XV yet.
     
  8. Frizzed WC Welker

    What ?
     
  9. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    Only a possibility at this stage and fairly unlikely. It'd be done differently from the Crabs anyway. Given how far post counts have moved, any other forum teams would only be entered into the reserve grade and I don't want a Bye in reserve grade, so somehow we'd need two new reserve grade only teams.
     
  10. Droos JP Rhodes

    We'd love to have our own team, but the fact is that there just enough of us and frankly never will be to make a full 15, so why not at an alternative like Proez suggested.
     
  11. Furball G Furball

    Can we not just abolish Celtic Provinces? They're a joke side.
     
  12. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    Based on those ratings and a few other things, here's what I'm thinking for Game 1:

    1 Dave Eggman
    2 Alan Izett/Tom Delonge
    3 Wes Welker
    4 Heath Davis
    5 Jason Denton
    6 Simon Humble
    7 Crossfire Hurricane
    8 Pretzel Spark
    9 Rob Cribb
    A Dion Alessi/Aaron Hunt
    B Ben Herd
    C Geoff Smith
    D Gareth Weaver
    E Lucas Schaw
    F Alistair Son/Regan Hutchinson

    16 Morgan Burridge/James Torres
    17 Sam Bakkum
    18 Benny Read
    19 Alex O'Driscoll/Dexter Astele
    20 Alistair Son/Regan Hutchinson
    21 Dion Alessi/Aaron Hunt
    22 Alan Izett/Tom Delonge

    Dexter Astele and Joshua Ritchie unlucky based on their Regional form, but there's too many quality front rowers for Ritchie to displace one, and based on his sub-provincial form (which was superb) I've opted for Pretzel Spark in the boot.

    Burridge's form in the Regional tournament was hard to ignore, but surely he isn't really a better option than Torres who didn't get many minutes - relatively speaking. O'Driscoll a wild-card based on good form for NSW.

    Izett vs. Delonge's an interesting one too. Delonge was good in the Regional tournament, but Izett was a shade better. Probably going for Delonge based on historical performances, but Izett should get some minutes.

    Alessi vs. Hunt. Well, Hunt had some good performances from the bench for NSW and Australia and again he might be a good impact option for South.
     
  13. azzal AJ O'Neill

    Strong lineup.
     
  14. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    Heads deserves consideration over Smith too.
     
  15. Jabba HJ Bots

    Interesting you find it worth playing schaw I found his defensive shambles too costly
     
  16. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    I don't think any of the alternative wingers are better enough. I wasn't exactly dazzled by the defensive work of Fiery, Taylor or Dorn out wide and Escath is much more likely to conjure something out of nothing. But he'd be on a short rope if he doesn't perform. Probably set the orders accordingly to sub him if he's proving a liability.
     
  17. Cribbage RG Cribb

    Spark playing is so legendary. Get that up ya, Crabs. :ph34r:
     
  18. Howe JHF Howe

    Our other #8s are North, so this doesn't really prove anything except how inferior your lot are
     
  19. Jabba HJ Bots

    Also heef rego on the wing would be better then escath possibly
     
  20. Cribbage RG Cribb

    I definitely think Burger is better than Benny ftr.
     

Share This Page