S5, P1: New Zealand vs. Baabaas - Completed

Discussion in 'Matches' started by HeathDavisSpeed, Nov 25, 2013.

  1. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    New Zealand

    Joshua Ritchie
    Alan Izett
    Chris Smith
    Jason Denton
    Heath Davis
    JD Hurricane
    Simon Humble
    Samuel Yates
    Sam Bakkum
    Matthew Scoble
    Matt Dorn
    Gareth Weaver
    John Heads
    Lucas Schaw
    Regan Hutchinson

    16 Kovana Solosolo
    17 James Torres
    18 Mike Martyn
    19 Dexter Astele
    20 Geoff Smith
    21 Dan Larkinson
    22 Sticky Phlegm

    Barbarians

    Os du Toit
    Jonty Rhodes
    Samuel Vimes
    James McDougal
    Double Dong
    Callum Laing
    Michael Chung
    Leumas Himann
    Cobra Classified
    Chad Dyer
    Andrew James
    Chuck Faldo
    Paddy Orr
    Chris Raftery
    Ginger Furball

    Substitutes

    Ishang Narang
    Hal Teja
    Siege Morgan
    Jono Chewie
    Zohaib Ikram
    Truman Lee
    Sachet Tuladhar
     
    Last edited: Dec 2, 2013
  2. Sultan Pepper HG Emm

    Draw written all over it
     
  3. Quaggas O du Toit

    Odds seem about right
     
    Last edited: Nov 25, 2013
  4. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    Preview: The first outing of the Barbarians in the Regional Rugby Championship will set the tone for their campaign ahead. They've put out a team featuring some seasoned campaigners as well as some up-and-comers, but will be hard pressed to come away with many points in the season ahead.

    In the match ups, the Baabaas only clear area of superiority is in the front rows. Jonty Rhodes has proved himself to be a reliable campaigner in the Hurricanes jersey this season - and outperformed Alan Izett, the experienced NZ hooker in their meeting in the SRC this season. The other front rowers should be tidy enough options, but Joshua Ritchie is having a 'Wheelson Season' and Os du Toit isn't doing much better. Chris Smith will focus on forcing du Toit up and out, whilst rookie Samuel Vimes will look to give Ritchie a working over.

    In the 2nd row, the advantage goes to NZ as the tried and tested 'Heefton' partnership of Heath Davis and Jason Denton take on a new pairing in seasoned veteran James McDougal and up-and-comer Double Dong. Much will rely on the two hookers' throwing at the line out, and both have proven to be at the reliable end of the scale this year. Davis and McDougal are likely to enjoy another heated battle - one of many over the years.

    The respective backrow line-ups look to join battle in what looks to be a mouthwatering prospect. Callum Laing and Michael Chung combine in a familiar Spartans pairing against the decent back row combo of JD Hurricane and Simon Humble. The Barbarians should have the upper hand here, but that tilt could be outweighed by Samuel Yates' supposed superiority over Leumas Himann. One further string to the Barbarians bow is that they have another quality #8 option on the bench in Jono Chewie and well as the solid form of Siege Morgan. If the match is close heading into the final 20, the battle between Chewie and Dexter Astele and Morgan versus Mike Martyn could prove to be pivotal.

    The back lines also look to have some interesting head-to-heads on the cards. Both Andrew James and opposite number Matt Dorn have shown good form in club contests so far, but James has arguably the greater pedigree. Not much defensive work will be done on their wing, and not much - if any more - on the other where Lucas Schaw surely could rip Chris Raftery a new one.

    In the centres and it's advantage New Zealand once more as Gareth Weaver will look to dominate the solid but less flashy Paddy Orr and John Heads will face down club-mate Chuck Faldo.

    At the full back position, we shouldn't expect to see many testing high balls as solid options are available for both teams in the form of Regan Hutchinson and Ginger Furball. The Barbarians will be hoping for no full back injuries as back up full back Sachet Tuladhar (Form = 3, 0, 4, 1, 0) will surely prove to be out of his depth here. In Tuladhar, the selectors have opted for a very defensive full back ahead of more flashy options like Girve Swervington or Cunning Stunt.

    The pivots should be another advantage to New Zealand - however, Cobra Classified has proven to be surprisingly solid in the season thus far and gets in ahead of bench option Zohaib Ikram or another option in reasonable form in Fourie van der Westhuizen. The experience of Matthew Scoble at first five should suit New Zealand's game plan, but look for Chad Dyer to try and limit Scoble's options as much as possible.

    Prediction: A bridge too far for the Barbarians at this stage. A victory to New Zealand by between 7 and 13 points.
     
    Last edited: Nov 25, 2013
  5. Himannv LV Himann

    Come on ye Baabaas!
     
  6. El Nino J Torres

    NZ 13+
     
  7. Arheiner SIA Yates

    We got this, expecting it to be close though, probably sub-10 points.
     
  8. SmellyStuff MP Chung

    Awesome writeup
     
  9. Magrat Garlick M Garlick

    dat front row ja
     
  10. Callum CJ Laing

    ChungaLaing got this.
     
  11. Furball G Furball

    Just smash them up the middle lads.
     
  12. Starris ER Starris

    Carn NZ...
     
  13. Howe JHF Howe

    with the gang?
     
  14. MASTERS S Masters

    10k on the Kiwis, make me some money
     
  15. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    I have at last simmed this. I'm hoping it'll be tonight, but a few commentary errors have been cropping up since I upgraded the commentary, so I apologise in advance for anything that makes no sense, and please highlight any issues.

    Not sure what time it'll be up, but probably late-ish NZT if at all (9pm, perhaps?)
     
  16. Quaggas O du Toit

  17. the_killerz S Bakkum

    Carb lads!
     
  18. Himannv LV Himann

    So keen!
     
  19. Starris ER Starris

    NZ all the way!!!
     
  20. HeathDavisSpeed HT Davis

    Doing a bit of loading for preparation, eh? Pasta all the way?
     

Share This Page