TBH, Yates has been always been solid and does a lot for us. Thats why i would rate him above Gemmell
Not as much as Gemmell though. He's scored a try a match (up until the Cheetahs match) and contributed to the team. I haven't seen Yates score week in week out and lead his team to a draw (albeit a 60min one ) against the Vikings when we were down and out.
There is news on a possible announcement, that is even better than simmage atm. I know this may seem like an excuse but I am working really hard on this, and if it comes off, Seasonal Rugby will improve by over 1000%.