Do you have a list of all the roles? Seems like I got a guilty report on pretty much every Barksdale.
So yeah, my identity couldn't be discovered by detectives, which I assumed meant I came up inno to cops as well. Apparently not
So you spent all game killing off various detective roles while the only traditional cop got everyone on the team. ggwp
I was wondering why I was leading such a charmed life. Sure with a watcher I was pretty safe but once Heef was gone I was certain I was about to go.
Given I didn't have a night action role, not surprising. Could have turned the lynch three times if I wanted to, but given my scumdar is the worst this side of the Ural, I felt I might as well wait with it to save myself.
Arbitrary player ranking 1. Heef 2. Athlai 3. Vimes 4. Skippos 5. Frizzed 6. Blunder 7. Captain 8. KATA 9. Mariner 10. N11 N/A Benny, logan, Starris, Teacups 15. Tartmaster 16. Gazza 17. Weeman27bob 18. Arheiner 19. Furball 20. morgieb 21. AVA
Yeah Heef had a cracker, twice I had guilty reports that weren't even required because he got them lynched anyway. Definitely kept me alive and took the early game away from them.
Seems harsh but I completely shat the bed by arguing to kill Arheiner when him revealing Skippos would've suited me.
Just went through my reports, got a red on every mafia except Starris who got killed by Omar. Some of that was the suss-dar but thats some pretty hard luck for team Barksdale.
Not a huge fan of the watcher role, as you have to look for different things - I.e. Who would mafia want to kill rather than who is mafia. Really wanted to investigate Furball as I was suspicious of him, but instead had to go for a different angle. Watching Arheiner was relatively obvious, but I had a good feeling that watching Frizzed would pay dividends. Frizzed played his role well, I thought.
In hindsight I pushed waaay too hard on weeman because I'd have needed to use the same defence as him had my plan worked as I'd have become a 3rd party survivor.
Definitely a case for best town (group) award in future Mafia awards. Quality game there Howe. Disappointing that Morgie took the momentum away a bit at the end there but it can be a bit hard submitting useless orders. What was his role? Random?
Pretty much. In the original 25-man draft of the game he could find 3rd parties but that didn't really make sense
I'd have scumbagged it even further "One off ability to go a psychic and get a cop report*" *Result still random
Had a very very useful ability and revealed himself too early IMO. I was always safe with my character claim. Would've taken a suicide CC from mafia to lead a lynch against me.
