Code: 1 COLLINGWOOD 2 HAWTHORN 3 WEST COAST 4 SYDNEY 5 CARLTON 6 GEELONG 7 FREMANTLE 8 ADELAIDE 9 ESSENDON 10 RICHMOND 11 NORTH 12 BRISBANE 13 BULLDOGS 14 PORT 15 ST KILDA 16 GOLD COAST 17 MELBOURNE 18 GWS now we're talking
That was pure overalls, for the record. This is a weighted score. Gives much higher priority to the elite players as well, you much prefer 7 stars + 15 goods than 22 greats Code: 1 COLLINGWOOD 2 HAWTHORN 3 WEST COAST 4 SYDNEY 5 ADELAIDE 6 GEELONG 7 CARLTON 8 FREMANTLE 9 RICHMOND 10 ESSENDON 11 NORTH 12 BRISBANE 13 BULLDOGS 14 PORT 15 ST KILDA 16 GOLD COAST 17 MELBOURNE 18 GWS
I tend to agree, but it's so marginal I can ignore it. This takes the sum of the best 22 players. They're going to have to play 2 KPFs who are ranked like 29 and 32 or suffer without playing any. If I forced the KPFs into calculations they'd fall to about = with stkilda.
Jesus you lot must have overrated your depth players. Apparently 55 is a second round draftee, so I'd like to see why everyone's is so high.
I've explained this already. It's due to the draft system - most clubs have fillers from late rounds on the list and Geelong are no exception. If Stringer, Walker, Sheringham and Schroder kick on etc. then you'll improve. Right now they're nothing more than decent VFL players.
I'd have picked it before tbf. They've had something like 26 elite draft picks come into the club over 3 years so a lot of their 'depth' is just top end talent waiting in the wings. Lynch, Thomas Horsley, Kyal Lonergan, Jesse Hall, Aaron Russell, Luke Martin, Jack (R) Wilkinson, Joel Hutchins, Jack Gorringe, Daniel Shaw, Matt Sexton, Alex Tape, Sebastian Osborne, Leigh (R) Nicholls, Tom These sort of players. Yeah, they're not great - but they're definitely good enough to be on an afl list and as far as depth go, you're laughing. As I said - you can almost expect depth to be the reverse of performance over the last 5 years.
Stringer, Walker and Sheringham all significant played AFL football last year, mate. Schroder played too. These boys played when Geelong was flying and winning games. If these guys (which I rated 65-70?) make Geelong the second worst for depth I shudder to think what you rate guys who aren't getting a game for Melbourne. These kids played before Shannon Byrnes, who is getting a game in he 1s for Melbourne...