Round 6 - Dereks v Chokers

Discussion in 'CPL AFL Matches' started by Skippos, Apr 16, 2014.

  1. Skippos SM Morgan

  2. Skippos SM Morgan

    Code:
    FB:	T. Jonas		R. Thompson		B. Reilly
    HB:	R. Henderson		A. Rance		H. Hartlett
    C:	J. MacRae		R. Sloane		B. Ebert
    HF:	T. Rockliff		J. Westhoff		D. Swallow
    FF:	T.T. Lynch		J. Daniher		L. Henderson	
    R:	N. Naitanui		N. Fyfe			J. Watts
    IC:	M. Shaw 	 	L. Ball			T. Mitchell	
    SUB:	M. Wright
    
    

    IN: N. Naitanui, T. Jonas, J. MacRae, M. Shaw
    OUT: M. Grigg (Omit.), T. Hickey (Omit.), D. Simpson (Omit.), R. Laird (Omit.)

    Omit:
    L. Whitfield
    R. Laird
    C. Sylvia
    A. Mullett
    T. Curren
    C. Dawes
    J. Hogan
    L. Neale
    A. Siposs
    D. Simpson
    T. Hickey
    M. Grigg

    Tactics:
    - Thompson to #1, Rance #2, Jonas to take resting ruck. If mismatch occurs move Henderson back
    - Reilly to 1st small, Shaw to take 2nd small.
    - Sub Wright in for one the weakest players which fits into the rotation
    - Mitchell, Rockliff and to a lesser extent Fyfe form a forward rotation
    - Rockliff to tag if need be.
    - Westhoff, Thompson and Daniher to form a ruck relief. Thompson to do it if he isn't needed down back/Henderson or Watts to cover, if he is then whichever of the Hoff and Daniher are doing worse fwd. Naitanui to ruck as much as possible though
    - If leaking/the match situation seems like it requires it move Watts into a loose man. If he struggles use Rance
    - Swallow/Hartlett to run loose.
     
    Last edited: Apr 19, 2014
  3. Harps ZAF MacDonald

    FB: Ash Smith - Tom Lonergan - Paul Duffield
    HB: Campbell Heath - Matt Maguire - Jarrod Harbrow
    C: Shaun Atley - Liam Shiels - Isaac Smith
    HF: Robbie Gray - Aaron Black - Brad Hill
    FF: Jeff Garlett - Sam Reid - Jack Fitzpatrick
    R: Todd Goldstein - Sam Mitchell - Andrew Swallow
    IC: Kieran Harper (sub) - Jake King - Andrew Gaff - Sam Gibson

    In: Gibson, Duffield
    Out: Murphy, Mohr
     
  4. Skippos SM Morgan

  5. Skippos SM Morgan

  6. Skippos SM Morgan

  7. Skippos SM Morgan

  8. Skippos SM Morgan

  9. Skippos SM Morgan

    CPL MVP:

    5 - Tom Rockliff: No real standout here, all 5 really were equal. 26 touches and 7 inside 50s does the job though
    4 - Sam Mitchell: 36 touches, 11 marks and 2 goals. Wasn't very efficient though.
    3 - Jackson MacRae: 32 touches, 14 marks but 6 clangers :/
    2 - Tom Lynch: 23 touches, 11 marks and 3 goals
    1 - Jack Watts: 20 touches, 3 goals and 4 clearances.
     
  10. Harps ZAF MacDonald

  11. Skippos SM Morgan

    Small defence... toothless attack, can't expect much more even if the midfield is gun.
     
  12. Harps ZAF MacDonald

    I'll figure it out soon.

    Going to shake the team up this next game and start selection from scratch.
     
  13. Skippos SM Morgan

    Yeah, and the beauty of it is that you'll get 22 new players next season.

    It's a balance thing more than anything really, reid and black are both okay 3rd best forwards on a list but neither are great 2nd fwds let alone 1st fwds, they'd both have performed at afl level having the 2nd/3rd best defender on them but in this they're getting the best and it's a step up. The smalls are okay but nothing special.

    You got flogged today though because you were conclusively smaller across the park. Each of my small defenders had about 5cm on your smalls, my tall backs had 5 cm on your talls, the midfielders had 5-10 midfielders and especially down forward, of the 7-8 blokes who spent time there (naitanui spent none, ftr, so this excludes him) they were: 201cm, 199cm, 196cm, 196cm, 191cm, 190cm while your defenders were 197cm, 192cm, 188cm, 187cm, 186cm and 178cm and the latter 4 are all small bodied ones.

    Just got outmuscled and outmarked; 50-60 more marks across a game makes it unwinnable, unfortunately.
     
  14. Harps ZAF MacDonald

    Will definitely be better in the draft next season.
     

Share This Page