2013 Brownlow Medal

Discussion in 'Aussie Rules Football Discussion' started by jimmy_c8, Apr 3, 2013.

  1. jimmy_c8 MC James

    Each year a few of my mates and I try and give Brownlow votes for each game that we watch and then have a bit of a flutter at the end of the season with most team votes, head to heads etc.

    It's hard to watch every single game so it would be good to get a few opinions on here as we all watch a lot of footy. Will be interesting to see how close we actually get to predicting it come the end of the year (it's impossible to predict as there are always some strange votes given but it's a bit of fun).

    From Round 1 we have the following:

    Adelaide v Essendon
    3. Watson
    2. Howlett
    1. Dempsey

    Fremantle v West Coast
    3. Barlow
    2. Mundy
    1. D Pearce

    Richmond v Carlton
    3. Cotchin
    2. Gibbs
    1. Deledio

    Collingwood v North Melbourne
    3. Pendlebury
    2. Swallow
    1. Cloke

    Geelong v Hawthorn
    3. Selwood
    2. Mitchell
    1. Mackie

    Gold Coast v St Kilda
    3. Ablett
    2. Dixon
    1. Unsure

    Melbourne v Port Adelaide
    3. Hartlett
    2. Br Ebert
    1. Kornes?

    Doggies v Brisbane and Sydney v GWS we didn't see.

    Feel free to discuss and add your own votes and I will put together a leaderboard each week during the year and see how we go.
     
  2. MatthewJay TA Miokovic

    Pretty accurate, not sure how well Cloke played.

    And yeah Kornes vs Viney vs Wines for the 1 vote.
     
  3. MatthewJay TA Miokovic

    Should keep this going to help betting come seasons end.
     
  4. Dirk Diggler DM Diggler

    Agree with the Geelong vs Hawthorn votes.
     
  5. Jager LO Townsend

    Mine.

    Michael Barlow 3
    David Mundy 2
    Danyle Pearce 1

    Ben Howlett 3
    Jobe Watson 2
    Courtenay Dempsey 1

    Trent Cotchin 3
    Bryce Gibbs 2
    Brett Deledio 1

    Ryan Griffen 3
    Will Minson 2
    Brett Goodes 1

    Josh Kennedy 3
    Shane Mumford 2
    Keiran Jack 1

    Gary Ablett Jr 3
    Charlie Dixon 2
    Jarryn Geary 1

    Kane Cornes 3
    Hamish Hartlett 2
    Jay Schulz 1

    Scott Pendlebury 3
    Andrew Swallow 2
    Steele Sidebottom 1

    Joel Selwood 3
    Sam Mitchell 2
    Andrew Mackie 1
     
  6. Skippos SM Morgan

    I do this every year and make a killing on the brownlow. I don't vote for BoG, I vote for perceived umpires' BoG
     
  7. MatthewJay TA Miokovic

    GWS vs Sydney

    3. Jack
    2. Kennedy
    1. O'Keefe?
     
  8. jimmy_c8 MC James

    That's the plan, hopefully we can keep the discussion going as the more people who get involved and give votes the better and hopefully more accurate it will be
     
  9. MatthewJay TA Miokovic

    Post them in here, running tally all year etc
     
  10. jimmy_c8 MC James

    Yep that's the big issue, trying to figure out what the umpires are thinking. That's why I gave Cloke 1 vote due to him taking some big marks at crucial times when we were either falling behind or trying to pull away.
     
  11. Mousey AJ Son

    This. Spot on imo
     
  12. brettman135 BR Hall

    3. Pendlebury
    2. Swan
    1. Swallow

    For Pies v North imo.
     
  13. Skippos SM Morgan

    Adelaide v Essendon
    3 - Watson
    2 - Howlett
    1 - Dempsey

    Dockers v Eagles
    3 - Pearce
    2 - Barlow
    1 - Hill
    Mundy robbed

    Carlton v Richmond
    3 - Gibbs
    2 - Cotchin
    1 - Walker

    Bulldogs v Brisbane
    3 - Griffen
    2 - Liberatore
    1 - Rockliff
    Minson robbed

    Sydney v GWS
    3 - Jack
    2 - Mumford
    1 - Kennedy

    Gold Coast v St. Kilda
    3 - Ablett
    2 - Dixon
    1 - Dal Santo

    Melbourne v Port
    3 - Hartlett
    2 - Kornes
    1 - Ebert

    North v Collingwood
    3 - Pendlebury
    2 - Swallow
    1 - Cloke

    Hawthorn v Geelong
    3 - Selwood
    2 - Mitchell
    1 - Mackie
     
  14. MatthewJay TA Miokovic

    Have to back Skippos in, but Walker over Lids?
     
  15. PaulFromOz PF Oz

    GAJ, that's all you need to know.
     
  16. Skippos SM Morgan

    If Deledio played in a pocket, would he deserve votes? If Milne had 17 touches, mostly effective and scored 3 goals he'd be far from votes. Deledio was nigh on nonexistent in the middle and popped up for some handy goals, yeah. I was disappointed with him.

    Walker shut down his opponent and completely diced open the game with his footskills all night. I'd say he was 2nd BoG behind Gibbs but the umpires won't give the 3 & 2 to players from the losing team.
     
  17. brettman135 BR Hall

    Since when do umpires notice players for shutting down their opponent?
     
  18. Harps ZAF MacDonald

    This thread will be gun come season end.

    I'll post up the votes I think from every game I watch.
     
  19. Stormer BH Borisc

    Pendlebury
    Swallow
    Cloke

    Griffen
    Minson
    Giansiracusa/Dalhaus
     
  20. jimmy_c8 MC James

    Very rarely does this happen, but a guy like Walker could get votes considering he got some of his own ball as well and uses it pretty well.
     

Share This Page